Estonia to close its border with Russia

As of 1 December, Estonia plans to close its three border crossing points with Russia in response to a foiled arson attack on an Estonian drone manufacturer. Tallinn has blamed the Russian military intelligence service GRU for the attack, but Moscow rejects the accusations. Commentators debate whether this measure can improve security.

Open/close all quotes
Postimees (EE) /

Long overdue and necessary response

Postimees is all for the closure:

“It goes without saying that the Estonian state must respond appropriately to an attack, and closing the Estonian-Russian border crossings is a suitable measure. All the more so given that, as a country on the EU's external border, we have been a transit country for Russian citizens visiting the EU up to now. Postimees already called for the border to be closed back in July, as the Finns had done before us. With regard to security cooperation with Latvia, it would be important to coordinate the border closure and carry it out jointly. Given that the Finnish-Russian state border is already closed, a joint action – which should have been organised long ago – would have a significant impact on Russia.”

Ilta-Sanomat (FI) /

A futile message

Ilta-Sanomat doesn't believe that closing the border will put an end to the hybrid attacks:

“This is a state-level response and a message to Vladimir Putin's Russia, which is constantly expanding its hybrid operations in Europe: enough is enough. ... Whether Putin is willing to comprehend this message is another matter. Probably not. Judging by the initial reactions, the Estonian border decision was deemed to be merely further proof of 'unbridled Russophobia'. Well of course. Russia has not admitted carrying out the attacks. ... Estonia's border decision is unlikely to prevent hybrid or cyberattacks. The perpetrators may already be in the country. Furthermore, Russia is recruiting people willing to carry out acts of sabotage online.”

Vot Tak (RU) /

Simple solutions rarely the right ones

Vot Tak columnist Sergey Kovalchenko warns that this is the wrong strategy:

“I am convinced that closing the border will not be such bad news for Putin and his spies and saboteurs, who undoubtedly wish to harm the Estonian defence industry. The ones who will suffer most are those who have elderly relatives in Russia who need care. And also those who, as a result of this decision, will no longer be able to see their loved ones, who, by the twists of fate and history, are scattered across different countries. Experience tells us that we should not look for ulterior motives where there are none. Simple solutions to complex issues are not always the right ones.”