Five EU countries to open deportation centre in Rwanda

Germany, Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands and Greece plan to jointly set up a deportation centre in Rwanda in 2027 for migrants who have exhausted their legal avenues to stay. Initially, it will be a pilot project with around 100 places for people who cannot be returned to their country of origin. The EU created the legal framework for such agreements with third countries this year. The project gets mixed reviews in the media.

Open/close all quotes
Politiken (DK) /

Challenging but promising

Although the decision could mark a turning point in migration policy, it also presents challenges, Politiken notes:

“The difficulty lies in ensuring that the deportations do not infringe upon the rights of those being deported. The big question is how Denmark and the other countries can guarantee this. ... The five countries will go to great lengths at the outset to ensure that the programme is a success for both themselves and Rwanda. ... Should the model prove viable in both practical and legal terms, it could be a 'gamechanger', as the Danish Prime Minister put it. But there is still a long way to go.”

Die Welt (DE) /

The last piece of the puzzle

Die Welt welcomes the plan:

“Leading migration researchers agree that, if implemented correctly, the principle can be put into practice in a legally sound manner. If the deportation component of the new asylum framework can be successfully implemented, the migration issue could indeed be regarded as having been resolved in the best possible way. People with a right to asylum will then be able to remain in Europe – and, thanks to falling case numbers, will receive more attention and opportunities. At the same time, Europe will be able to concentrate more resources on recruiting people it needs for the labour market.”

Der Standard (AT) /

Disrespectful and morally questionable

Der Standard is appalled:

“Europe, the 'continent of human rights', will ship 'unwanted foreigners' off to a completely unfamiliar third country whose language they do not speak and to which they have no ties. ... Asylum procedures lay down rules for deciding whether to grant protection or not. However, they do not cover how repatriation is to be carried out in the event of a negative outcome. This is a matter for bilateral repatriation agreements, which in practice have to be painstakingly negotiated and are often immoral – like, for example, the talks with the Taliban. Europe now wants to rid itself of this unpleasant task and is passing on the problem to those directly affected, who are to be sent, like packages, to a far-away country. This is disrespectful and highly questionable from a human rights perspective.”

Süddeutsche Zeitung (DE) /

Not the right approach

The Süddeutsche Zeitung sees the plan as yet another expensive symbolic project:

“There are around 260,000 people in Germany who are required to leave the country. Twenty of them are due to be transferred to Rwanda next year. The cost: up to 20 million euros. And the number of people to be deported is unlikely to rise significantly in the coming years. This brings to mind the debacle in the UK. By the time the courts declared Rwanda an unsafe destination for refugees and halted the plan for an asylum centre there, London had already invested hundreds of millions of pounds. Even advocates of an open society do not dispute that certain changes are needed in German asylum policy. ... The Rwanda plan, however, will not solve any of these problems.”

El País (ES) /

A false solution instead of humane management

El País points to a wave of migrants in the Canary Islands, with more than 13,000 reaching the islands in November alone:

“The best way for Spain to tackle xenophobia is to manage migration effectively. ... Allowing a sense of chaos to take hold inevitably leads to questionable shortcuts and false solutions – such as the proposal to set up deportation centres in Rwanda which has been given the green light by the European Commission. ... The sea constitutes the Canary Islands' border with Africa. On the other side, war, poverty and oppression prevail. ... As long as this reality remains unchanged, migration is not a problem to be solved, but a phenomenon that must be managed – with humanity and resources.”