Ukraine: new, realistic proposals?
According to press reports, Russia presented a document at the negotiations in Abu Dhabi calling for Nato to withdraw to its 1997 positions. In addition, Volodymyr Zelensky has said that the US has asked the Ukrainians whether they would be prepared to cede the Donbas region in exchange for Ukraine joining Nato. The media review both options.
Kremlin has no plans for peace
In a Telegram post republished by Echo, human rights activist Anastasia Burakova says Russia is bluffing:
“Clearly these demands are unrealistic and unachievable and are being put forward merely to provoke a refusal, so that they can throw up their hands and say: 'See, their very existence is a threat to us. They won't agree, so we will destroy and isolate the country by any means necessary until the very end.' ... The only conclusion is that the Kremlin has no plans whatsoever for peace in Europe. ... Warfare in various forms will continue for as long as Putin remains in power.”
Good that Europe is now on board
Even if Putin's demands are absurd, they remain dangerous, Der Tagesspiegel warns:
“Because with his talk of a 'new peace order' he could succeed in persuading Donald Trump and his inexperienced negotiators Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff to make concessions the far-reaching consequences of which they do not even grasp. Hence, it is all the more important that Europe is not merely consulted from time to time during the negotiations but from now on has a seat at the table. After all, this is not just about Ukraine, it's about Europe's security.”
Crude diplomacy
The proposal to trade the Donbas for Nato membership is disgraceful, Corriere della Sera fumes:
“Because what is to be handed over to the despot in Moscow remains priceless to this day. Almost five years after the invasion of Ukraine, the Russian army has failed to conquer a region that it had boasted it could take within hours. ... Secondly, by offering Nato membership Trump is proposing something that is not within his power to grant. And he is humiliating Nato by treating it as his personal property without even consulting it. The proposal is all the more indecent given that Putin is using the substantial disarmament of the states that belonged to the Warsaw Pact (or the Soviet Union) prior to 1989 as a bargaining chip.”
An exchange is not capitulation
La Repubblica takes a positive view of the US proposal:
“It has moved beyond the mere declarations of principle that Moscow and Kyiv had exchanged so far, and has now, for the first time, succeeded in addressing the actual, hidden crux of the negotiations. And, as always, the crux of the problem for Moscow is territorial. ... Ukrainian territory returning to Russian control in exchange for the definitive transition of a Ukraine mutilated by the loss of Donbas to the Western sphere of influence. We are faced with the first real chance of a turning point after four years and eight months of war in the heart of Europe. This plan has the potential to bring about peace because after so many maximalist declarations it envisages an exchange rather than the surrender of the occupied to the invader.”
Just a test
Political scientist Volodymyr Fesenko warns on Facebook against confusing informal exploratory talks with an official negotiating position:
“This may have been an attempt to gauge Ukraine's willingness to withdraw its troops from Donbas under certain conditions. Or it may simply have been tactical manoeuvring on the part of the Americans. In any case, at this stage this is neither an official position nor an official offer from the US. ... Nato accession is a lengthy process that can be blocked by any member state. The withdrawal of troops from Donbas, on the other hand, would have to take place before this process even begins. That is why one should not take such tactical token offers too seriously.”
Uphold the Helsinki principles
Europe must put forward its own proposal, argues Huffington Post Greece:
“The starting point of any discussion must be the Helsinki principles: sovereign equality, territorial integrity, refraining from the threat or use of force, and the right of every state to choose its own alliances. Ukraine decides on its own sovereignty. Europeans decide jointly on their own security. On this basis, specific risk-reduction measures can be discussed: military communication channels, rules of conduct for aircraft and warships, transparency regarding exercises, inspections and arms controls. Communication channels are particularly crucial in times of tension. However, their operation must serve to prevent conflict without legitimising spheres of influence.”