Putin, Xi and Trump meet: the upshot?

The leaders of China, Russia and the US convened at an historic meeting on Thursday in Shenzhen, China. After an hour and a half of discussing the global situation the host Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump issued a four-point joint "peace declaration" stressing that nuclear wars must be prevented at all cost and nuclear risks reduced through further dialogue. The media take stock.

Open/close all quotes
La Stampa (IT) /

Emphasis on sovereignty rather than human rights

The Chinese approach has prevailed, La Stampa comments:

“It aims to lay the foundations for a new era of 'global cooperation' based on the minimum common ground between the key players and respect for state sovereignty. ... The desire to reform the UN, to secure each country's energy supply, to protect the sovereignty of nations from intervention by the International Criminal Court and to avert nuclear war outlines a series of initiatives on the international stage that consigns international law to history. ... The legacy of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is giving way to a reaffirmation of state sovereignty which, spearheaded by the three most powerful and influential nations, is emerging as the basis for a reorganisation of the global security order.”

Diena (LV) /

What matters is what follows

For Diena, the summit has the potential to usher in a new world order:

“The meeting in Shenzhen was, in a sense, a symbolic acknowledgement by all participants that the old world order no longer exists. ... Its true significance can only be gauged by whether it is followed by regular dialogue, concrete negotiation mechanisms and, above all, a genuine willingness to compromise. Should this be the case, the meeting could turn out to be the first step towards a new system of international relations. Otherwise, it will remain merely a symbolic moment in which, while the need for negotiations was briefly acknowledged, no compromises were reached and the rest of the world was never convinced of their necessity.”

Salzburger Nachrichten (AT) /

Putin is the biggest winner

The Kremlin can chalk up the trilateral meeting as a diplomatic success, Salzburger Nachrichten concludes:

“The biggest winner at this summit was Vladimir Putin. Russia has been excluded from key international forums since the annexation of Crimea in 2014. And since the invasion of Ukraine, the country has been largely isolated in the West. The fact that Putin now stands alongside the leaders of the world's two largest economies and can present himself as one of them carries enormous symbolic significance. Putin, whose war of aggression has cost thousands upon thousands of lives, is being welcomed onto the world stage as a 'friend' of Trump and Xi. These images alone are a diplomatic coup for the Kremlin.”

Neue Zürcher Zeitung (CH) /

Xi's power on the world stage growing

The Neue Zürcher Zeitung highlights China's growing importance:

“While Putin gains kudos as a guest, the summit highlights Xi Jinping's rise to power on the world stage. It is the diplomatic pinnacle of his term in office. And most importantly for China's Communist Party leadership: the meeting was smooth and controlled. ... Moreover, Xi Jinping is in an advantageous position. He is the only one at the table who doesn't have to bring a costly war to an end. Putin is waging war against Ukraine, Trump against Iran. Xi can receive both and present himself as a peacemaker, even though Chinese trade supports both Russia's and Iran's arms industries.”

Politiken (DK) /

Making peace could be so easy

The "peace declaration" issued by the three leaders after the summit should be followed by action towards resolving their own wars, Politiken notes:

“If the three presidents wanted peace, there would be a very simple solution: Russia withdraws immediately from Ukraine, which Putin himself invaded. The US ends its war against Iran, which Trump himself started. And China stops threatening Taiwan's independence. They need neither summits nor joint declarations to decide this. They can just do it. Better today than tomorrow.”